| 51 | Roger Bresnahan (Portrait) |
 |
| 52 | Roger Bresnahan (With Bat) |
 |
| 53 | Al Bridwell (Portrait No Cap) |  |
| 54 | Al Bridwell (Portrait With Cap) |  |
| 55 | George Brown (Browne) (Chicago) |  |
| 56 | George Brown (Browne) (Washington) |
 |
| 57 | Mordecai Brown (Chicago On Shirt) |  |
| 58 | Mordecai Brown (Cubs On Shirt) |  |
| 59 | Mordecai Brown (Portrait) |
 |
| 60 | Al Burch (Batting) |  |
| 61 | Al Burch (Fielding) |  |
| 62 | Fred Burchell |  |
| 63 | Jimmy Burke |  |
| 64 | Bill Burns |  |
| 65 | Donie Bush |  |
| 66 | John Butler |  |
| 67 | Bobby Byrne |  |
| 68 | Howie Camnitz (Arm At Side) |  |
| 69 | Howie Camnitz (Arms Folded) |  |
| 70 | Howie Camnitz (Hands Above Head) |
 |
| 71 | Billy Campbell |  |
| 72 | Scoops Carey |  |
| 73 | Charley Carr |  |
| 74 | Bill Carrigan |  |
| 75 | Doc Casey |  |
| 76 | Peter Cassidy |  |
| 77 | Frank Chance (Batting) |  |
| 78 | Frank Chance (Portrait Red Background) |  |
| 79 | Frank Chance (Portrait Yellow Background) |  |
| 80 | Bill Chappelle |
 |
| 81 | Chappie Charles |
 |
| 82 | Hal Chase (Holding Trophy) |
 |
| 83 | Hal Chase (Portrait Blue Background) |
 |
| 84 | Hal Chase (Portrait Pink Background) |
 |
| 85 | Hal Chase (Throwing Dark Cap) |
|
| 86 | Hal Chase (Throwing White Cap) |
 |
| 87 | Jack Chesbro |  |
| 88 | Ed Cicotte |  |
| 89 | Bill Clancy (Clancey) |
 |
| 90 | Josh Clark (Columbus) (Clarke) |
 |
| 91 | Fred Clarke (Pittsburgh Holding Bat) |  |
| 92 | Fred Clarke (Pittsburgh Portrait) |
 |
| 93 | J.J. Clarke (Cleveland) |  |
| 94 | Bill Clymer |  |
| 95 | Ty Cobb (Portrait Green Background) |
 |
| 96 | Ty Cobb (Portrait Red Background) |
 |
| 97 | Ty Cobb (Bat Off Shoulder) |
 |
| 98 | Ty Cobb (Bat On Shoulder) |  |
| 99 | Cad Coles |  |